Not sure where to start? Take the free Stage Intelligence Read and get your communication profile in 4 minutes. Not sure where to start? Get your speaking profile in 4 minutes. Take the free ReadFree Read

How to give feedback on a presentation without crushing someone

Give useful presentation feedback with practical examples, a five-point checklist and clear questions to ask about your own presentation.

By Richard Ford ·

A colleague finishes a presentation. It was fine. Not terrible, not brilliant. They look at you and ask, “How did that go?”

You have two easy options. You can say “Great, really good,” which helps nobody. Or you can pour out everything you noticed, which helps nobody and may ruin their afternoon.

There is a better route. It takes less time than either, and people tend to be grateful for it.

Step one: ask what they were trying to do

Before you say a word about the talk, ask: “What were you hoping people would take away?”

It does two things. It shows you are interested in their goal, not just your own taste. And it gives you something to measure against. A presentation can be quiet, plain and exactly right for the room, or loud and slick and aimed at the wrong target.

Ask intent

What were they hoping people would take away?

Say what worked

Specific and true.

Offer one try

Described by its effect on you.

Step two: say what worked, and be specific

“Good job” does not teach anything. “When you told the story about the failed launch, I understood why the change mattered” does. Specific praise tells the person what to repeat.

It also has to be true. People can tell when praise is a cushion for criticism coming next. If something genuinely worked, say it. If you cannot find anything, look harder or wait until you can.

Step three: offer one thing to try

Not five. One. Pick the change that would make the biggest difference.

Frame it as something to try, and describe what it did for you as a listener. Compare:

  • “Your slides were too busy.”
  • “On the third slide I stopped listening to you because I was reading. What would happen if there were only one number on it?”

The first judges the person. The second describes an experience and invites a solution. People can argue with a judgement. They can hardly argue with how something felt to you.

Presentation feedback examples you can actually use

Useful feedback names a moment, explains its effect on the audience and offers one practical next step. These examples are starting points: use only what you actually observed.

Message: “Your opening gave me three priorities, but I was unsure which mattered most. Could you lead with the one decision you want us to make?”

Evidence: “The customer example made the problem clear. I still need to understand how typical that experience is. Could you add one relevant figure and explain what it means?”

Delivery: “When you paused after the recommendation, I had time to take it in. Try that same pause after your main finding.”

Slides: “I was reading the paragraph while you were making a different point. Could you leave the conclusion on the slide and say the detail aloud?”

Ending: “I understood the issue, but I was not sure what you wanted from us. Finish with the action, who owns it and when it needs to happen.”

A five-point presentation review checklist

Message: Can the listener explain your main point in one sentence?

Structure: Does each section help the audience follow the argument, with clear transitions?

Evidence: Do examples and figures support your claim, and have you explained their relevance?

Delivery: Are your pace, pauses and volume helping people understand you?

Next step: Is it clear what the audience should think, decide or do afterwards?

Use the checklist to choose the most useful improvement. Do not turn it into five separate criticisms delivered at once.

A short cheat sheet

  1. Intent. “What did you want them to take away?”
  2. Worked. One specific thing that landed.
  3. Try. One change, described by its effect on you.

Things that help it land

  • Ask permission. “Would you like some thoughts?” sounds small and changes the mood.
  • Do it soon, but not instantly. If the person is still buzzing or shaky, an hour later is often better.
  • Keep big feedback private. A quiet chat beats a public critique every time.
  • Skip the “but”. “That was great, but…” makes everything before it disappear. Use “and” or start a new sentence.
  • Match the person. Some people want the lot. Some need one gentle point. Ask which they would prefer.

If you are on the receiving end

You do not have to defend yourself. A simple “Thanks, that is useful” is plenty. Pick the one thing that rings true and try it next time. You are allowed to leave the rest.

How to ask for feedback on your own presentation

Give your reviewer the audience, the time limit and the outcome you want. Then ask: “What did you think my main point was?”, “Where did you need more explanation or evidence?” and “What is the one change that would make this easier to follow?”

Good feedback is not about being nice or being tough. It is about being useful, in a way the other person can actually hear.

For a board presentation, ask whether the recommendation and decision are clear. For an investor pitch, ask whether the problem, evidence and ask stand up to challenge. A rehearsal or recording lets your reviewer comment on delivery as well as slides.

Want feedback on a presentation you are preparing? Bring it to a 40-minute Room Review (£95). We will identify what is working, what needs attention and the most useful next steps for your audience.

Make it a team habit

When a team shares the same simple language for feedback, it stops being scary. People start asking for it. Presentations get better because everyone is practising in a safe place, not because someone was told off.

Good feedback is not about being nice or being tough. It is about being useful, in a way the other person can actually hear.

Next step: If you would like your team to practise giving and receiving feedback on real presentations, look at our workshops for teams. Or bring your own to a Room Review for honest, kind feedback you can use.

Richard Ford, founder of Life Is A Speech, seated in a café
You don’t need to become someone else to hold a room.

Meet Richard

I’ve sat where you’re sitting.


I’ve spent 25+ years in business, including working at Vodafone, Syngenta and JD Sports. I know what it’s like to walk into a room with the numbers, the plan and the pressure to get people on board.

Alongside that, I’ve performed improv, written comedy and spent years on stage. The Edinburgh Fringe is a remarkably efficient way to discover when something isn’t landing.

Today I bring those two worlds together in coaching. I understand the business pressures, know how to hold attention, and help people communicate with clarity and confidence without feeling like they’re putting on an act. And that’s Stage Intelligence Coaching.

Richard FordFounder, Life Is A Speech

Stage Intelligence Coaching

The Stage Intelligence Read

Before you step into the room, know what needs your attention.

Take the free Read

4 minutes · Personalised results · Free

Room Notes

Useful thinking for your next important conversation.

Get Room Notes for practical ways to make your message clearer, your delivery stronger and your next conversation easier to handle.

Bring this to your own room.

Take the free Stage Intelligence Read to see where your message needs attention, or book a 40-minute Room Review (£95, taken off any coaching you book afterwards).

Request a Room Review Take the free Read